Stoicism

The ten gifts of Apollo

Marcus Aurelius's ten reflections for the moment anger stirs.

In Meditations 11.18, feeling anger stir, Marcus Aurelius doesn't suppress it or reason it away in the abstract. He reaches for a list (nine reflections from the Muses, and a tenth from Apollo himself) and works through it deliberately. Robertson surfaces this passage as a core Stoic self-therapy toolkit.

Seneca passed on an old saying: anger is "a brief madness." What follows is Marcus working his way back out of it.

The ten gifts:

  • We are made for each other — Humans are social creatures, built to cooperate. Anger works against our nature.Beehive: Justice's bee from the four virtues, at the hive it belongs to; work against the hive and the bee loses too.
  • See the whole person — Look at their life and context, not just the act that irritated you.Spectacles: put them on and the one act shrinks to its place in a whole life.
  • No one does wrong willingly — People act badly from ignorance or confusion. They deserve understanding, not rage.Root: not-seeing, the affliction yoga's other four grow from; nobody wrongs you from clear sight.
  • You have the same capacity — You've done similar things, or could. This dissolves self-righteous anger quickly.Two figures: them and you, drawn alike, because what they did is in you as well.
  • Everything passes — The situation, the person, and the anger itself are all transient. Nothing here is permanent.Melting ice cube: impermanence's mark from the three marks page, and the anger is ice as well.
  • Anger harms you more than them — It poisons your mind and body while leaving the other person relatively untouched.Poison bottle: hatred is one of Buddhism's three poisons, and the one holding the bottle is the one who drinks.
  • It's your judgement, not the event — The event is indifferent. Your belief that you've been wronged is what creates the pain, and that belief is yours to examine.Gavel: nothing hurts until the ruling comes down, and the gavel is in your hand.
  • Understand their motives — Try to see why they acted that way. Understanding usually softens what outrage hardens.Shoe: theirs, worn a while, because most acts make sense from inside them.
  • Kindness is the antidote — Genuinely cultivate warmth toward them. Opposite emotions tend to displace each other.Open door: loving-kindness's mark from the four abodes, the opposite the three poisons page sets against hatred.
  • Apollo's gift — stop expecting perfection — It is unreasonable to expect flawed human beings never to act wrongly. Accept this as a condition of life, not a shocking injustice.Anchor: equanimity's mark from the four abodes; someone will do wrong today, count on it, and you hold steady without going cold.

Sources: Marcus Aurelius — Meditations 11.18; Donald J. Robertson — How to Think Like Socrates

Anger met from the inside, as it happens Anger →